|
Feminism and Theological Liberalism |
|
Written by chuck
|
|
Thursday, 26 October 2006 |
|
I stumbled across this piece by Al Mohler this morning. Now, I must admit to a predisposition to disagree with Mohler. He seems, most of the time, to be "majoring on the minors," as one person put it--tending to argue about those hot button issues that really rile up his "base," but which seem on the margins in importance. In this particular piece, he is worried about "evangelical feminism." Why? Because, according to him and Wayne Grudem, it undermines biblical authority by pushing too hard "egalitarian" themes in relationships between men and women. At least, that what seems to be at stake, since he is not as clear as one would like. He does admit that the use of the term "liberalism" is problematic, and then goes on to say that you are liberal if you do not deny "the complete truthfulness of the Bible as the Word of God and denies the unique and absolute authority of the Bible in our lives." (quoting Grudem)
What is so striking about this is that just about anyone can accuse just about anyone else of being "liberal" on this definition, since it seems ultimately to be grounded in a commitment to a literalism (notice how one letter makes such a difference) that does not allow for much nuancing in biblical interpretation. Since he does not get into much detail about what parts of "egalitarianism" the two of them object to, it is difficult to see what he is worried about. Yet, I have many colleagues who would affirm both the authority of Scripture and egalitarianism, and they would argue that Mohler and Grudem are simply misreading Scripture.
The question all this raises for me is: how do we actually begin to have serious dialog about issues such as this? Mohler's piece is little more than an attempt to "circle the wagons" by encouraging his followers to keep out the dangerous evangelical feminists. Do you suppose we might ever get to the point where we actually tried to understand what the other side was saying, and then engage each other in legitimate give and take--without appeal to simplistic critiques rooted in ways of reading the bible that we ourselves do not even adhere to unconditionally?
Original content by: http://imitatiochristi.blogs.com/imitatio_christi/2006/10/feminism_and_th.html.
|
|
Last Updated ( Thursday, 26 October 2006 )
|
Articles, Media, and More 
Scott Bartchy is a radical. He believes in a subversive system that embraces those on the fringes of our society and seeks to establish a new way of life that goes against the status quo.